Beyoncé’s attorneys are as soon as once more asking federal regulators to register Blue Ivy Carter’s title as a trademark, greater than 12 years after she and Jay-Z first sought to lock up the mental property rights to their daughter’s title.
In a movement filed final week on the federal trademark workplace, legal professionals for Beyoncé’s firm pushed again on a ruling earlier this 12 months that customers would possibly confuse the title with one other Blue Ivy: a single-store clothes boutique in Wisconsin that has used the title since earlier than the younger Carter was born.
The star’s legal professionals say that ruling ought to be overturned, arguing that no one goes to confuse Beyoncé and Jay-Z’s daughter — as soon as dubbed the “most well-known child on this planet” — with a small clothes store.
“No cheap client would ever endure any type of confusion when encountering the [store’s] emblem, which is used with one small store in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, an unincorporated group with a inhabitants of roughly 997 individuals,” Beyoncé’s attorneys write. “Nor would an inexpensive client encounter the ‘Blue Ivy Carter’ mark and conclude that the well-known Carter household had teamed up with a small store in rural Wisconsin to launch a clothes line.”
An legal professional for Beyoncé’s firm didn’t instantly return a request for touch upon the standing of the trademark case.
Simply weeks after Blue Ivy was born in January 2012, Beyoncé’s BGK Trademark Holdings LLC utilized on the U.S. Patent and Trademark Workplace to register her uncommon title as a trademark. The transfer raised eyebrows on the time, as followers questioned if the couple was commercializing their daughter. However Jay-Z later advised Vainness Truthful that they merely needed to forestall her title from being exploited by others.
“Individuals needed to make merchandise based mostly on our youngster’s title, and also you don’t need anyone attempting to learn off your child’s title,” he advised the journal in 2013. “It wasn’t for us to do something; as you see, we haven’t carried out something.”
Greater than 12 years later, nevertheless, Blue Ivy’s mother and father have but to safe that trademark registration.
For years, the method was slowed down in authorized disputes with a lady named Veronica Morales, who runs a life-style occasion planning firm below the title “Blue Ivy” and secured her personal trademark to it. In 2020, a tribunal on the USPTO rejected Morales’ complaints, ruling that the 2 sides’ respective choices have been “so dissimilar that confusion is unlikely.”
That ruling seemingly cleared the way in which for the “Blue Ivy Carter” trademark registration to lastly be issued. However attorneys for BGK by no means moved that utility ahead, and finally, the USPTO deemed the applying deserted final 12 months.
In November 2023, Beyoncé’s attorneys utilized but once more for a similar trademark registration. Like earlier efforts, nevertheless, the brand new utility rapidly hit a roadblock: In April, a trademark examiner issued a tentative ruling that the mark was “confusingly comparable” to the title of the Wisconsin clothes retailer, which has owned a trademark registration on its “Blue Ivy” emblem since 2011.
(The Wisconsin boutique itself just isn’t truly concerned within the case and has not filed an opposition to the Blue Ivy Carter trademark; as an alternative, the USPTO merely cited the sooner trademark as a motive to disclaim Beyoncé’s utility.)
It was this tentative denial that Beyoncé’s attorneys challenged final week, arguing that Individuals know who Blue Ivy Carter is and would by no means suppose she was “one way or the other related to a beautiful boutique store in a small city in rural Wisconsin.”
“Because the second she was born, she has resided within the American public’s conscience and thus … the consuming public would affiliate her with a trademark bearing her title,” BGK’s legal professionals write. “The events every exist and thrive in their very own separate worlds and might proceed doing so into the longer term.”
Supply hyperlink